Popular Searches:
Pokémon Platinum ranks as the best DS Pokémon game, offering superior storytelling and difficulty compared to Diamond and Pearl. HeartGold/SoulSilver, Black 2/White 2, and Black/White round out the top tier, each excelling in different areas like nostalgia, post-game depth, and narrative strength.
The Nintendo DS hosted some of the franchise’s finest games. From 2006 to 2012, the handheld saw five generations of Pokémon titles that introduced Wi-Fi trading, touch-screen mechanics, and storytelling that still holds up today. But which DS Pokémon game is actually worth your time?
The answer depends on what you’re after. Want a challenge? Platinum. After pure nostalgia? HeartGold/SoulSilver delivers it with a Pokéwalker accessory. Looking for endless post-game battles? Black 2/White 2 won’t disappoint. We’ve ranked the top five DS Pokémon games to help you pick the right one.
The DS era marked a turning point for the franchise. These games introduced online trading and battling through Nintendo Wi-Fi Connection—no cable link required. The touch screen lets developers experiment with new controls and inventory systems. Dual-screen layouts created more space for battle animations and map layouts than ever before.
Gen 4 brought the Pokéwalker, a pedometer that let you train Pokémon while walking around in real life. Gen 5 ditched handholding and forced you to face unknown creatures, creating genuine discovery. These innovations made DS Pokémon games feel fresh while staying true to the core formula. That’s why fans still replay them today.
Pokémon Platinum is the definitive Sinnoh experience. It improves on Diamond and Pearl in almost every way.
The most obvious upgrade: battle speed. The animations in Diamond and Pearl dragged on so long that some battles felt like watching paint dry. Platinum cuts these in half without sacrificing quality. You’ll notice the difference immediately.
Platinum also expands the Pokédex. Diamond and Pearl forced you to use mostly Sinnoh natives until postgame, leaving you stuck with limited type coverage. Platinum adds Pokémon like Electabuzz and Magby to earlier areas, making team building less frustrating.
The rival battles—especially against Cynthia—hit harder here. Cynthia runs one of the toughest champion teams in the entire series. Her Garchomp hits like a truck. Even overleveled players can lose if they’re careless. That difficulty creates real stakes.
Story improvements are subtle but meaningful. Gym leader dialogues are clearer. The legendary lore around Dialga and Palkia makes more sense. Cyrus’s plan to remake the universe feels more threatening. These tweaks add weight to the campaign.
The postgame is solid but not exceptional. You can battle other players on Wi-Fi, catch the Legendary Pokémon Giratina, and fill out your Pokédex. It’s enough to keep you engaged for another 20 hours, but Black 2/White 2 offers more.
Who should play it: Players who want a balanced experience—strong story, real challenge, and a game that doesn’t waste your time.
HeartGold and SoulSilver remake the Game Boy originals with modern conveniences and one standout feature: the Pokéwalker.
This pedometer accessory syncs with your DS. Every step you take in real life earns experience for Pokémon inside it. You can even catch rare Pokémon that don’t appear in the main game. It sounds gimmicky, but it genuinely changes how you engage with the game. You’re training Pokémon while going about your day.
The emotional hook runs deeper here than in other remakes. You see your favorite Pokémon following you on screen. In battle, they respond to your commands with personality. These small touches build attachment in ways pure mechanics can’t replicate.
The story hits different, too. Returning to the Johto region—and later Kanto—feels like coming home. The campaign spans two regions, doubling your playtime. Gym leaders and legendary beasts feel nostalgic yet fresh.
The downside: HeartGold/SoulSilver are the most expensive DS Pokémon games on the secondary market. Cartridges regularly sell for $100+. The game is also easier than Platinum, so veterans might breeze through it.
Who should play it: Anyone who wants to reconnect with the classics, enjoys the emotional side of Pokémon, or values the physical Pokéwalker experience.
Black 2 and White 2 deliver the most postgame content of any DS Pokémon title. After beating the champion, you’re not done—you’re barely started.
The headline feature is the World Tournament. This lets you battle all gym leaders and champions from previous games. It’s a celebration of the entire franchise and a genuine endgame that gives your team purpose. Leaderboards and rematches keep you coming back.
The Challenge Mode adds artificial difficulty. Your opponents use held items and better movesets. It transforms casual battles into genuine tests.
The story itself is strong. It takes place two years after Black/White, and the Unova region has evolved. New areas appear, and the cast feels more mature. Team Plasma returns with darker motives. It’s a sequel done right.
One caveat: Black 2/White 2 are the rarest DS Pokémon games. Availability is limited, and prices reflect that. You might spend $150+ on a cartridge. But if you find one, the value is there.
Who should play it: Completionists and competitive players who want postgame battles that actually matter.
Black and White took a risk. Instead of mixing old and new Pokémon, the main story forces you to use only Gen 5 creatures. You see them all fresh, without relying on nostalgia.
This design choice works. You’re genuinely discovering new Pokémon. The team you build feels earned, not safe.
The story is the franchise’s strongest. N, the antagonist, isn’t a simple villain. He believes Pokémon should be free, and his philosophy has merit. Watching him and the protagonist clash creates moral weight. Team Plasma’s plot to “liberate” Pokémon feels complex rather than cartoonish.
Gym leaders have deeper personalities. Their dialogues reveal genuine character. Even minor NPCs feel fleshed out.
The catch: Black and White are the easiest games in this list. Levels scale below what you’d expect, and trainer AI isn’t great. Veterans can steamroll through. The postgame is also light—you get Wi-Fi battling and that’s mostly it.
But if you’re new to Pokémon or want to experience pure story, Black/White are the entry point.
Who should play it: Story-focused players, newcomers to the series, or anyone who values narrative over grinding.
Diamond and Pearl founded the Sinnoh story. They’re not bad games. Platinum just outclasses them.
The battles move slowly. The Fire-type availability is brutally limited (only Chimchar as a starter). The water coverage is ridiculous—half your encounters are water Pokémon. These design quirks make the early game frustrating.
If you can’t find Platinum or it’s too expensive, Diamond/Pearl still delivers. Cynthia still dominates. The legendary lore still captivates. You just need patience with the pacing.
Who should play it: Budget-conscious players or completionists who need all three Sinnoh games.
| Game | Best For | Difficulty | Post-Game | Story Quality |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Platinum | All-around experience | Moderate-Hard | Solid | Strong |
| HeartGold/SoulSilver | Nostalgia and emotion | Easy-Moderate | Good | Classic |
| Black 2/White 2 | Endless content | Moderate | Excellent | Very Strong |
| Black/White | Pure story | Easy | Limited | Best-in-series |
| Diamond/Pearl | Budget pick | Moderate | Solid | Strong |
Physical cartridges are your best option. Search eBay, local game stores, or retro retailers. Prices vary wildly. Black 2/White 2 command premium prices ($100+). HeartGold/SoulSilver are also expensive ($80-120). Platinum runs $60-80. Black/White are cheapest ($30-50).
You’ll need a Nintendo DS, Nintendo DS Lite, or Nintendo DSi to play. Original models are rare and fragile. DS Lite units are still common and reliable. Avoid the DSi for Pokémon—some Gen 4 games have known issues.
Emulation exists as an alternative, but official cartridges support the original developers and preserve the authentic experience. The Pokéwalker feature only works on real hardware, too.
Modern alternatives exist if you can’t find or afford these games. Pokémon Legends Arceus on Switch reinvents the formula. The Sinnoh remakes, Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl, modernize those stories (though they’re more casual than Platinum). If you want the pure original experience, the DS games remain unmatched.
Your choice depends on what you want from Pokémon.
Play Pokémon Platinum. It’s the best Sinnoh game and among the best in the series.
Grab HeartGold or SoulSilver. The Pokéwalker integration and following Pokémon create memories that newer games can’t replicate.
Black 2 and White 2 deliver. The World Tournament alone justifies the price if you can find it.
Black and White offer the franchise’s most thoughtful narrative. Don’t sleep on them.
Diamond or Pearl works, but Platinum is worth the upgrade if you can afford it.
Whichever you choose, you’re getting games that hold up. These aren’t relics. The mechanics work. The stories matter. The battles still challenge. Twenty years later, the best Pokémon DS games remain genuinely worth playing.
